GTA 6 Reviews Are In: A 99 on Metacritic Ties the Highest-Rated Game Ever
Metacritic has GTA 6 at 99, tied with Ocarina of Time. The embargo lifted Nov. 18, the launch is Nov. 19, and the scores can still move.
Grand Theft Auto 6 sat at 99 on Metacritic on the afternoon of November 18, 2026, tied with Ocarina of Time (1998) for the highest rating on the site. The embargo lifted at 6 a.m. ET, Kotaku reported. This desk read the boards between about 5 and 5:30 p.m. ET. The numbers can still move.
The scores
Kotaku’s tally at the time of writing: 145 reviews on Metacritic, every one of them positive, and a 9/10 as the lowest score on that list. The 99 ties The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (1998).
OpenCritic showed a Top Critic Average of 99, with 99% of critics recommending the game. Kotaku and Polygon had both reported 98 earlier in the day.
Off the Metacritic list, the lowest score found anywhere was a 4/5 from ScreenHub, via the BBC.
Perfect scores also came from Edge, Forbes, Game Informer, GamesRadar+, Push Square, The Guardian, The Washington Post, and VGC, per Vice’s roundup.
The numbered reviews in front of us:
- IGN, Luke Reilly: 10/10
- GameSpot, Tamoor Hussain: 10/10
- Eurogamer, Chris Tapsell: 5/5
- PlayStation LifeStyle: 9/10
- Noisy Pixel: 9/10
- Slant Magazine: 4.5/5
- ScreenHub: 4/5
Kotaku’s Zack Zwiezen did not publish a score. Neither did Polygon’s Giovanni Colantonio, or The Verge.
What critics loved
Reilly’s 10/10 is the bluntest rave in the stack. “Exquisitely detailed, endlessly ripe for experimentation, and uncompromisingly engineered, Grand Theft Auto 6 is the single most impressive video game I have ever played,” he wrote, as reported by GameSpot.
Hussain, in GameSpot’s own 10/10, called it “an astonishing open-world action game that I’d wager won’t be outdone until Grand Theft Auto 7.”
Chris Tapsell’s 5/5 for Eurogamer: “Rockstar pushes back the horizon of video games once again with GTA 6.”
Zwiezen, writing at Kotaku with no score, called it a “masterpiece of open-world design”.
The Verge’s headline says the game “does something impossible — it lives up to the hype.”
Noisy Pixel’s 9/10 calls the protagonists “compelling”. ScreenHub, even at the bottom of the pile, still calls the game “lovingly rendered”. The New York Times, via the BBC, called it a “dense game filled with friction.”
What critics knocked
Hussain’s reservation, in that same GameSpot review: “Gated progression points can disrupt pacing.”
Polygon’s roundup calls the story “uneven and padded with repetitive chases.” Colantonio, who did not score the game, wrote that “GTA 6’s empathy is bound to be the most controversial thing about it”.
The Verge’s knock is about the shooting, not the score. “The combat is still clunky, and the weapon wheel is still frustrating.”
ScreenHub’s 4/5 is the floor. Large sections, the BBC relayed, are “boring and too limited.”
PlayStation LifeStyle’s 9/10 still flags performance. The frame rate “frequently” drops and is “inconsistent”.
Noisy Pixel’s 9/10 calls the pacing “uneven” and the police response “unpredictable”.
Slant Magazine, at 4.5/5, says the game takes “power away from the player” at checkpoints.
Kotaku did publish criticisms in Zwiezen’s review. They are only available as a translated paraphrase, so this desk is not quoting them.
The backlash on X
The 99 did not land quietly.
DiscussingFilm’s score-roundup post was at 11.3 million impressions and 169,000 likes by about 5 p.m. ET on Nov. 18.
Plenty of accounts are calling the reviews paid, or the game overrated. We found no evidence of paid reviews.
The other fight is frame rate. Posts compare how critics treated Cyberpunk 2077’s launch with GTA 6 dipping into the mid-20s fps on a base PS5. That figure is being cited to Digital Foundry, per an X news summary, and it should be read as reported, not as a number this desk measured. Trailer-versus-game shots of the beach are spreading next to it.
Should you buy it
Launch is November 19, 2026, on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S. It rolls out from midnight local time, New Zealand first. NBC News and Engadget both have that window. Standard edition is $79.99. Ultimate is $99.99. A PC version, and GTA Online, are expected in 2027.
The money is already booked. Sensor Tower put pre-order revenue at $1.1 billion, on 11.3 million copies, by November 10. Take-Two was up more than 6% in premarket trading on November 18, Reuters reported.
Buy the 99 and you are also buying the caveats attached to it. A 10/10 flags pacing gates. The 9/10s flag an inconsistent frame rate and uneven pacing. The lowest mark anywhere, a 4/5, calls stretches of it boring and too limited. The aggregate can still move overnight. The launch does not wait.
Sources
- Kotaku (opens in a new tab)
- BBC (opens in a new tab)
- OpenCritic (opens in a new tab)
- Polygon (opens in a new tab)
- Vice (opens in a new tab)
- GameSpot review (opens in a new tab)
- GameSpot on the IGN verdict (opens in a new tab)
- The Verge (opens in a new tab)
- DiscussingFilm on X (opens in a new tab)
- NBC News (opens in a new tab)
- Engadget (opens in a new tab)
- Sensor Tower (opens in a new tab)
- Reuters via Investing.com (opens in a new tab)
